Julia Roberts as Tinkerbell
Caroline Goodall as Moira
Phil Collins as Inspector Good
Isaiah Robinson as Pockets
Raushan Hammond as Thud Butt
Thomas Tulak as Too Small
Alex Zuckerman as Latchboy
Bogdan Georghe as Lost Boy
René González Jr. as Additional Lost Boy
Brian Willis as Additional Lost Boy
Brett Willis as Additional Lost Boy
Ryan Francis as Young Peter
Max Hoffman as 5 Year Old Peter (as Maxwell Hoffman)
Kelly Rowan as Peter's Mother
Stephanie Furst as Mermaid
Shannon Marie Kies as Mermaid
Regina Russell Banali as Mermaid (as Regina Russell)
Jewel Newlander Hubbard as Peter Pan in Play
Jeannine Renshaw as Drama Teacher
Rebecca Hoffman as Jane in Play
Jeannine Wagner as Pianist
Francesca Serrano as Lost Boy in Play
Kevin Gasca as Lost Boy in Play
Andre Bollinger as Lost Boy in Play
Lauren Friedler-Gow as Lost Boy in Play
Bryce Armstrong as Lost Boy in Play
Margie Takeda as Lost Boy in Play
Alyson Healing as Lost Boy in Play
Zoe Koehler as Lost Boy in Play
Scott Williamson as Coach
Michael Hirshenson as Umpire
Jake Hoffman as Little League Player (as Jacob Hoffman)
Geoffrey Lower as Brad (as Geoff Lower)
Don S. Davis as Dr. Fields
Brenda Isaacs Booth as Secretary (as Brenda Isaacs)
Stuart White as Chauffeur
Don McLeod as Mime/Shadow
Kim O'Kelley as Prostitute
Beverly Polcyn as Prostitute
Randi Cee as Prostitute (as Randi Pareira)
Mary Bond Davis as Prostitute
Tony Burton as Bill Jukes
Nick Ullett as Pirate Jailer
Matthew Van Ginkel as Baby Peter
Ray Tveden as Man in Stands
Kim Robillard as Toothless Cripple
Michael Runyard as Screaming Pirate (as Mike Runyard)
Gary Epper as Growling Pirate
G. Larry Butler as Baseball Game Attendee
Mickey Cassidy as Colonial Lost Boy
Russell Gannon as Blacksmith
Robert Gatewood as Pirate
Bruce Mercury as The Drunk Pirate
Devin Schumacher as Pirate
Steven Spielberg as Pirate
Lisa Wilhoit as Baby Tinkerbell
Mark Winn as Praising Pirate